• About
    • About
    • What is Public Interest Communications?
    • Our Team
    • Theories We Use
    • What We’ve Shared
    • Center Updates
    • Programs & Affiliates
      • frank gathering
      • The Research Prize in Public Interest Communications
      • Journal of Public Interest Communications
      • UF Programs
    • Contact Us
    • Job: Center Research Assistant
  • Our Services
    • Strategy Consulting
    • Issue Research
    • Training – Frameworks and Custom
  • Frameworks & Resources
  • Training
    • Programs
    • Now Recruiting
      • Beyond raising awareness: How to create lasting change
      • Strategic Communications Academy for UF Leaders & Scholars
      • UF Science Communication Short Course
  • Case Studies
Center for Public Interest Communications
Support
  • About
    • About
    • What is Public Interest Communications?
    • Our Team
    • Theories We Use
    • What We’ve Shared
    • Center Updates
    • Programs & Affiliates
      • frank gathering
      • The Research Prize in Public Interest Communications
      • Journal of Public Interest Communications
      • UF Programs
    • Contact Us
    • Job: Center Research Assistant
  • Our Services
    • Strategy Consulting
    • Issue Research
    • Training – Frameworks and Custom
  • Frameworks & Resources
  • Training
    • Programs
    • Now Recruiting
      • Beyond raising awareness: How to create lasting change
      • Strategic Communications Academy for UF Leaders & Scholars
      • UF Science Communication Short Course
  • Case Studies
  • Case Study

Covering immigration in local news—an exploration by Define American

  • October 26, 2022
  • 3 minute read
illustration of hand holding United States flag
Total
0
Shares
0
0
0
0

In 2022, the Center for Public Interest Communications was engaged by Define American to assist with a report they were developing around the narratives on immigrant policy and communities.

The project, “Reimagining Immigration News: North Carolina’s Case for the Nation” focused on the local media ecosystem in North Carolina as proxy for what is happening across the U.S.

Define American, a national group looking at immigration issues, identified a challenge they saw of rising xenophobia and changing demographics, and the perspective that media need to cover all communities accurately so that people have the information to understand their neighbors. 

The report blends traditional reporting from 50-plus interviews with stakeholders, with a content analysis conducted by the Media Ecosystems Analysis Group, as well as an audience survey of North Carolina news consumers conducted by the University of Florida’s Center for Public Interest Communications. 

READ THE REPORT

Subtle but significant: Centering news coverage on storytelling drives deeper audience engagement.

How the Center helped

The Center team activated experts in media effects, solutions journalism, message design and other disciplines. The Center provided an analysis of North Carolina media consumers and conducted a content design experiment that informed the findings.

The project was led by Center Director of Research Annie Neimand, Ph.D., and Research Associate Jack Barry, Ph.D., with assistance from Center Director Ann Searight, Director of Trainings and Programs Ellen Nodine and Managing Director Matt Sheehan. Neimand and Barry also activated the Center’s research network and engaged partner faculty from the UF College of Journalism and Communications, including:

  • Juliana Fernandes, Ph.D., assistant professor in advertising
  • Elizabeth ‘Lissy’ Calienes, director of the professional master’s program and lecturer in advertising
  • Rachel Grant, Ph.D., assistant professor in journalism
  • Kim Walsh-Childers, Ph.D., professor in journalism
  • Frank Waddell, Ph.D., associate professor in journalism

Methodology

Audience Survey: The purpose of the study was to understand the relationship between beliefs and attitudes about immigrants and immigration and their trust in local and national news in North Carolina. Quota sampling was conducted via an online survey of 1,160 participants using a Qualtrics panel to mirror the population of North Carolina. The data were analyzed to examine the relationships between demographic and psychographic factors, trust in local and national news, and attitudes toward and knowledge of immigrants and immigration.

Hierarchical regression was used to test how demographic variables, media trust, institutional trust, moral values, cultural worldview, multicultural ideology, colorblind ideology, and systems thinking predict immigrant attitudes, immigration attitudes, immigration positions, support for immigration increase, and immigrant knowledge. Five total regressions were conducted – one for each outcome variable.

Audience Experiment: To explore the effectiveness of storytelling on attitudes and beliefs toward immigrants and immigration, the research team also recruited participants using a Qualtrics quota panel of people living in North Carolina. We excluded respondents who had liberal views on immigration as defined in a series of questions adapted from the organization More in Common’s report Speaking to Core Beliefs on Immigration report. For the in-group theory experiment, 179 participants were recruited. The experiment included too few people to mirror the demographics of the state. For the full experiment the demographics were: 65% female, 31%, male, 82% white/Caucasian, 13% Black/African American, 3% Latinx or Hispanic heritage, 2% Asian, 25% age 18-38, 45% age 39-64, and 30% age 65+.

To manipulate various aspects of the in-group theory elements, we used a real story (original condition) published in ABC-11 News (story linked here) and created two versions: a story containing only partial elements of the in-group theory (partial condition) and a story containing just facts ( just facts condition). For the partial condition story, any language that mentioned the characters of the story as in-group was removed. Examples of that were American, the NC community. For the condition of the just fact, language was changed to factual information, excluding any mentions of emotions. For the original condition, we maintained the story closely as it was originally published on ABC-11 News.

First, participants were asked to read an informed consent detailing the purpose of the study. After they consented to participate in the study, a series of pre-test questions were asked about their immigration knowledge and attitudes. After answering these questions, participants were randomly assigned to one of the three news stories. They were asked to take a moment to read the story in its entirety as they would be asked questions about it. After reading the story, participants answered a series of questions related to the story. The final block of questions asked about participants’ demographics and psychographic variables. Finally, participants were shown a debriefing statement revealing that some elements of the news story they read were modified for this study and a link that they could follow to read the original story.

0
0
0
Total
0
Shares
Share 0
Tweet 0
Share 0
Previous Article
BROKE project screenshot
  • Case Study
  • Scholarship & Publications

Re-examining narratives on poverty and wealth — the BROKE project

  • August 3, 2022
View Post
Think we can help with your goals? Read about our services and how we work.
Or reach out today to tell us a bit about your project and inquire how we might help.

 
 

Join our network

We'll send insights and opportunities when you least expect

More of our work
  • To Win Against False Information, We Must Play Offense
  • BROKE project screenshot
    Re-examining narratives on poverty and wealth — the BROKE project
  • How to Tell Stories About Complex Issues
  • Persuasion in a “Post-Truth” World
Latest from the Center
  • Teresa Gonzales and Nicole Bronzan
    Paper exploring local discursive frames of poverty and race wins 2023 research prize
  • Center welcomes two collaborators in research and strategy
  • 2023 Research Prize Finalists
    Center announces three finalists for the $10,000 public interest communications research prize
  • Rakeem Robinson
    Center honors the memory of colleague Rakeem Robinson
How We Help – Case Studies
  • hands with medicine
    Invest in Trust – a vaccine communications guide for CNAs
  • gloved hand holding vial
    Science-based communication strategy on COVID for the UN Verified Initiative
  • Strategic Communications Academy for University of Florida Engineering Scholars

Subscribe

Keep up with our latest; request our periodic newsletter.

UF Logo

Center for Public Interest Communications
PO Box 118400
Gainesville, FL 32611-8400

An auxiliary unit of the College of Journalism and Communications

Copyright © 2022

Contact Us

We are eager to chat with you about your project or training need.

Send us a note

The Center for Public Interest Communications, the first of its kind in the nation, is designed to study, test and apply the science of strategic communication for social change. We are based at the University of Florida College of Journalism and Communications.

  • Social Change Communication
  • Science Communication
  • Strategic Communication
  • Broader Impacts
  • Public Interest Communication
  • Narrative Change
  • Leadership Development
  • Strategy Development
  • Effective Presentations
  • Research Translation & Insights

Input your search keywords and press Enter.